Pay Yourself First—Even When Money's Tight

If you’ve ever told yourself:

“I’ll save what’s left after I pay my bills…”

...and then realized there’s nothing left to save—you’re not alone.

For a lot of young professionals, especially those with growing or high incomes, it feels like no matter how much you earn, the money disappears just as fast.

The car note. The rent. The student loans. The food delivery. The gym you barely go to.

By the time it all adds up, your savings account is still at zero. And you’re left wondering:

"Where did it all go?"

That’s where the principle of paying yourself first comes in. It’s simple, powerful, and honestly, life-changing.

In this post, I’ll break down what it means, why it works, and how to actually apply it—even if money’s tight. I’ll also share a few stories along the way from my own journey.

What Does "Pay Yourself First" Actually Mean?

At its core, paying yourself first means treating your savings like it's the first bill you owe, not the last.

It’s a shift in mindset:

From “I’ll save what’s left over”
to “I’ll spend what’s left after I save.”

Instead of waiting until the end of the month to see if there’s anything left, you build your budget around your savings goal from the start.

It’s not about deprivation, it’s about intentionality.
It’s about telling your money where to go, instead of wondering where it went.

Why This Principle Works (Especially for Ambitious Professionals)

Let’s get real for a second. Income isn’t the problem for most people reading this.
It’s how that income is managed.

The more money you make, the more lifestyle creep shows up:

• Nicer clothes

• Fancier dinners

• Uber instead of walking

• Vacations to “destress” from a job you might not even enjoy

But here’s the thing: money will always find something to do, unless you tell it what to do first.

Paying yourself first sets the foundation. It builds margin. It creates breathing room. And over time, it builds freedom.

My Turning Point with This Principle

A few years ago, I found myself making a solid income, just over six figures, but still broke. Like, couldn’t-rub-two-pennies-together broke. Or, as my father would say: “Didn’t have a pot to piss in.” (Shout out to Caribbean parents.)

My savings account was bone dry. And I couldn’t figure it out.

This was the most money I had ever made… so why didn’t I have anything to show for it?

Eventually, I got tired of the cycle. I swallowed my pride and asked my dad for advice. And he hit me with this line:

“It’s not how much you make, it’s how much you save.”

It was one of those old-school sayings passed down like financial folklore.
I got the message, but I still didn’t know how to apply it.

So I asked him, “Okay, but how? Where do I start?”

Here’s how the conversation went:

Dad: Do you have a 401(k) at work?
Me: Yes.
Dad: Do you contribute?
Me: Yep.
Dad: Do you miss the money in your paycheck?
Me: Not really.
Dad: Exactly. Why do you think that is?
Me: Because it’s taken out before I ever see it?
Dad: Right. So you don’t spend it. Do the same thing with your paycheck. Either have your employer deposit part of it into another account, or set up an automatic transfer yourself.

It hit me like a lightbulb.

He had just taught me two game-changing principles:
1. Pay yourself first.
2. Automate it.

So I took action. I opened a separate account and had part of my paycheck deposited there directly.

I started with just $100 per pay period. And just like he said, I didn’t miss it.

Over time, I watched that account grow. And with every increase, I felt more motivated to save. That habit is now how I save for everything: down payments, vacations, investments. It started with one simple, intentional move.

How to Pay Yourself First (Even If You Think You Can’t)

You don’t need a massive income. You need a repeatable system.

Here’s how to get started:

Step 1: Pick a Starting Percentage

Choose a small, realistic percentage of your take-home pay.
10% is ideal, but 5% is a great place to begin.

Let’s say your paycheck is $2,000:

• 10% = $200

• 5% = $100

Can’t do that? Start with $50. Or $20. The dollar amount doesn’t matter, the habit does.

Step 2: Open a Separate High-Yield Savings Account

Don’t let the money sit in your checking account. It’ll disappear.

Open a separate online savings account, ideally one that’s not linked to your debit card. It adds just enough friction to keep you from casually spending it.

Step 3: Automate It on Payday

This is where the magic happens. Set up an automatic transfer on the same day you get paid.

Even better? If your employer allows it, split your direct deposit and send your savings portion straight to that second account—just like I did. When the money never hits your main account, it doesn’t feel like it’s missing.

Step 4: Give the Money a Purpose

Saving without a purpose can feel like a chore. Give your account a name:

• “Future Home Fund”

• “Financial Freedom Fund”

• “I Quit My Job Fund”

When money has meaning, it’s easier to protect, and more exciting to grow.

Step 5: Increase the Amount Over Time

Once you’ve adjusted to saving 5–10%, challenge yourself.

Try bumping it to 12%. Then 15%. Eventually, you might be stacking away 20% or more, and still living well.

Common Excuses (and Why They Don’t Hold)

“I don’t make enough to save.”
If you’re spending on Netflix, DoorDash, or weekend drinks, you can save something. Start small and build.

“I have too much debt.”
You can do both. Saving protects you from falling further into debt during emergencies.

“I’ll start when I make more.”
More income without a system just means bigger expenses. Build the habit now.

What Happens When You Actually Stick to This

Here’s what I’ve seen (in myself and in others I’ve worked with):

• You stop stressing about emergencies

• You stop relying on credit cards for “just in case” moments

• You start seeing your account grow, and realize you’ve built real security

• You create momentum, and that momentum makes everything easier

A Real Example

As I mentioned earlier, this method completely changed my financial life.

One of my favorite examples? The time I saved $13,500 in one year to pay for a new roof.
You can read the full breakdown of that story [here].

That wasn’t luck. That was paying myself first, and doing it consistently.

Final Thoughts

Paying yourself first isn’t just for the rich. It’s for anyone who wants to be intentional about their money.

And once you start? It’s hard to go back.
It feels good to look at your account and see options, not obstacles.

You don’t need to be rich to live with financial purpose.
You just need a plan, and a little consistency.

Ready to Build Your Plan?

If this resonated with you and you’re ready to build a system that works for you—your lifestyle, your goals, your paycheck—I’d love to help.

👉🏽 Book your coaching session here
👉🏽 Subscribe to the newsletter for one powerful money tip every week

You don’t need to be perfect.
You just need a plan.
And it starts by paying yourself first.